Customer crop editor in review
Make crop editor feedback show the intended frame
Show the crop frame and preview in your product together so a ratio mismatch has a concrete visual reference.
- ✓Presets update only part of the editor
- ✓Ratio changes move the subject unexpectedly
- ✓Preview and file checks get conflated
Crop findings with a visible target frame
Frame-to-preview comparison
Keep both representations visible when a preset changes only one of them.
Subject-position rules approved
Make recentering or preserving the crop an explicit editor design decision.
Output claims separated
Avoid treating a scaled preview as proof of generated file dimensions or quality.
Review the crop tool in your application
This page concerns an image crop editor inside your customer's product, not an image editing capability supplied by Retick. Use a harmless test image with clearly distinguishable corners and a central subject. Capture the initial crop rectangle, aspect-ratio control, zoom setting, and preview. Record the intended output shape and viewport. A preview is useful evidence of what the editor displays, but it does not establish the dimensions or metadata of a generated image file.
Show the frame before and after a ratio change
Record moving the crop area off center, switching from a free ratio to a square, and inspecting the preview before applying. An example issue is Square preset updates the handles but leaves the preview at the previous wide ratio. Include both the canvas and preview in the capture. Separate a stale preview from an incorrectly exported image unless you have independently checked the output. Avoid inferring exact pixel coordinates from a scaled screenshot.
Agree on the crop interaction contract
Upload supported screenshots or recordings into Retick, or capture the browser editor. Inspect AI candidate issues, edit unsupported output claims, reject assumptions about image encoding, and annotate the disagreement between handles and preview. Example acceptance criteria: the selected ratio is reflected by the crop frame and preview; switching presets follows the product-approved subject-position rule; and canceling restores the previous visible edit state. Have the image tool owner decide whether a ratio change recenters the crop before making that an acceptance requirement.
Follow up with awkward image shapes
After implementation, manually repeat with a portrait image, a very wide image, and the smallest supported source. Check handle movement and zoom boundaries through direct interaction. Verify exported dimensions, orientation handling, and image quality with separate file inspection and application tests. Retick does not crop source images, validate processing pipelines, or guarantee lossless output. Use authorized sample imagery and remove private photographs before capture; redaction is not automatic.
Download approved findings for a manual file handoff, or export selected issues from the individual media item to a connected Trello board and list. Include the starting crop position and preset change so engineering can reproduce the mismatch without mistaking the task for a general image-quality complaint.
Review an image crop transition
Capture the off-center frame, ratio change, and resulting preview.